Monday, May 12, 2008

Movie Monday: Movie to TV to Movie

I am so behind on my movies! The number of movies I need to watch just keep stacking up and then leaving the theaters. Boo! Stay there until I watch you, movie!

Today's post will be about movies and television. Some movies are based on television shows (i.e. Sex and the City, X-Files, the Simpsons Movie, South Park, and all the Star Trek movies). Some television shows are based on movies (i.e. My Big Fat Greek something I don't remember because that show was on for like two minutes).

Clearly it is not a good idea to base a television show on a movie unless you animate it (Clerks), change it completely (Buffy the Vampire Slayer), or are MASH (MASH).

You can get a[n unreliable, probably incomplete] list of tv shows based on movies here. (Here's another list that has multiple lists, and you know, multiple is better.)

Movies based on tv shows on the other hand have built-in fan bases. Movies usually don't have the same kind of viewer loyalty a television show has for the following possible reasons:

-The person liked a two hour movie, and now you expect them to tune in week after week to watch some watered-down version of it?

-We create addiction through anticipation. There is more anticipation with shows than with movies because you get to anticipate weekly. Exceptions are movies that have sequels (like Star Wars and Pirates of the Caribbean) and of course movies based on tv shows (or books or comics or etc.).

-Movies may cost more, but they aren't interrupted with mundane commercials. Why watch the ad-ridden show when you can just pop in the movie?

-Making something that was small much bigger equals WIN! Making something big into something small...LOSE.

-If it's a movie, it's special. You cheapen it by making it available to the masses with a gaggle of talentless writers who are writing for the show because they couldn't write the awesome movie that the show was spawned from.

We all want to see our favourite shows in a multiplex, but seeing a favourite movie with a different cast, different writers, different directors...oh, hell, it just doesn't work!

3 comments:

Britni said...

I completely agree... the only way it ever works is going from TV to the bigscreen, not vice versa. And actually those movies normally do pretty well because of their TV followings.

Technodoll said...

I still can't tell whether you prefer movies or the tv shows, LOL!

I'm guessing movies, but spank me if I'm wrong...

Um... Yum! said...

I prefer movies that are based on tv shows as opposed to tv shows that are based on movies. :o) of course there are exceptions to both.